Saddle Bags vs. Shopping Basket Battle Royal

commuting chronicles, gear review

When I first started trialing ways to transport goods on my bike, there were some obvious solutions: paniers, baskets, an extra cycle… But as usual, cost, self installation, and low maintenance were of the utmost importance. For these reasons the finalists became saddle bags or a shopping basket. The following is a review of the pros and cons of each.

Saddle Bags:

Saddle Bags are great form many uses. Transporting goods to and from work, certainly if you are locking up your ride in a bike room, bringing goods to a friends house, etc. Additionally, in terms of physics, bikes distribute weight best (i.e. you don’t have to work as hard peddling) when it is low, paniers fulfill this requirement. For my lifestyle, I didn’t like that bags I could afford weren’t quick release. I can’t always park in a bike room and I would like to remove the devices quickly and easily if I need to. Also, the bags are super awkward to carry once you do remove them. It would be possible to come with a locking mechanism and I have continued to consider this.

Shopping Basket:

Perhaps the most attractive trate of the shopping basket is that it makes a statement: I am poor, please don’t steel from me. Living as simply as possible creates alignment with people around you, unfair distribution of wealth drives theft (i.e. rightfully or wrongfully, having nice things encourages steeling). This is a principle I have used often when traveling, it isn’t 100%, but I have had success following it so far. Also, a backpack can be put into the basket which, once arrived at your destination, can be carried on ones back. Although, during the ride, in the basket, weight isn’t carried low, depending on how much weight, the rider doesn’t really know the difference for the convenience of having a backpack.

In summation, if there was an inexpensive easy to remove backpack which was also a saddle bag, or a locking saddle bag devise than I would reconsider, however, so far, for the convenience, the basket aids the rider in avoiding all kinds of hassle.

Pointer: Securing the basket long ways with a short bungie wrapped through the seat helps for stabilization.

2 thoughts on “Saddle Bags vs. Shopping Basket Battle Royal

  1. Dude, just put your stuff in a backpack when you’re riding. Or, if you’ve already got a rack, you can make some amazing panniers/buckets out of a rectangular kitty litter bucket. They’re usually free, are waterproof, and already have a handle. The mounting hardware is easy to make and cheap. Plus, you can put stickers all over them. Here’s an example:
    Plenty of mounting options. I’ve got one on my grocery-getter bike and it’s lasted years.
    They also have the added bonus of making you look like a cat-lady, which ought to deter thieves.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s